When project intake is weak and the right questions are not asked up front, costs show up fast: priorities drift, teams overcommit, projects stall, risks stay hidden, benefits are missed, and resources snap back and forth. The result is spinning teams and shaky sponsor confidence, while the portfolio fills with work no one can realistically deliver. It is expensive in time, dollars, and trust.
In conversations with organizational leaders about better portfolio delivery, I am often asked: “If I had to invest in one process to jumpstart improvements to our Portfolio Management to drive outcomes, which one would you recommend?” I almost always answer, “Project Intake”. Great project intake improves portfolio outcomes and value delivery. Without it, the likelihood of project success is reduced significantly.
My recommendation: Invest in intake.
The Project Management Institute’s Benefits Realization Management Guide starts value with Develop Business Case → Authorize Charter, PMBOK’s value-delivery model depends on clean information flow and decisions, and PMI’s governance and portfolio standards make selection and alignment the core of performance, all of which are executed through a strong intake gate.
What Does Great Intake Look Like?
• Fosters simplicity, practicality, and thoroughness together.
• Includes the right roles to execute the process end to end.
• Requires a simple business case that explains the problem: Why now, options, value, high level estimate and early risks.
• Includes using a strong governance structure as the decision making body during project selection. (We’ll cover this in a future article…stay tuned).
• Gives the governance team enough information to decide early and sponsor the work.
• Confirms requests as project work vs. business as usual (BAU) vs. a minor enhancement so it flows to the right lane.
• Aligns requests to strategy and the portfolio so decisions reflect outcomes and benefits.
• Plants benefits thinking and measurement from the start.
• Creates visibility in a single source of truth system of record.
• Sets the project manager and core team up for success day 1.
Common intake checklist (A Sample)
(Role Check: Requestors, Sponsors, Portfolio Managers, Program/Project Managers, Resource Managers, PMO Admins)
- Business case that covers problem, why now, value hypothesis, options, ROM (Rough Order of Magnitude. Estimates), early risks.
- Answer the right questions up front and captures just enough to decide. Refine later through the project life cycle.
- Route to the right lane: Project, operations or small enhancement under the threshold.
- Align to portfolio themes or mandatory buckets and check capacity.
- Authorization pathway, usually in small steps: Idea -> Assessment -> Initiation -> In Flight.
- Create the project record in the source of truth.
- Early governance one pager for approved, hold, or more assessment needed.
- Document decisions, assumptions, owners, and dates in the record.
- Connects to a staffing process to assign the project manager, core team and start structured communication. Pro Tip: Ensure the Portfolio Manager & Resource Manager set the PM up for success with a day 1 Sponsor intro and any relevant documentation.
- Draft initial benefits measures and confirm who owns them.
Misconceptions to Squash
You need everything figured out at intake: You do not. Get enough to decide, then use stages and checkpoints to refine scope, schedule, and cost.
Non strategic work does not belong in intake. It does. Mandatory, compliance, risk reduction, contractual, and run work follow a different path and capacity plan. Value includes risk reduction and cost avoidance. Tailor standards to what works for your organization.
Intake is bureaucratic. It should be minimum viable and flexible. Keep only steps that improve clarity, speed, or outcomes. Ditch the rest or your customers will work around the process.
Quick note on the charter
Business case earns the yes to initiate. The charter follows and formally authorizes the project and the project manager. For small or urgent items, use a charter lite and finalize quickly.
Bottom Line
Great project intake improves portfolio outcomes and value delivery. Without it, the likelihood of project success is reduced significantly. Simplify. Measure. Ask sharper questions. Route work correctly. Make it visible. Start strong and enable your project teams to deliver with confidence.
Leave a Reply